6 ISSUES FOR JUST £6 Subscribe to Business & Professional Life today CLICK HERE

Young drivers in South West deem black box scheme ‘unfair’

PUBLISHED: 16:36 04 May 2018 | UPDATED: 16:36 04 May 2018

Young Drivers Infographic (c) jalderjeffs

Young Drivers Infographic (c) jalderjeffs


Research has found that 43% of young drivers in the South West are unhappy having to rely on schemes like the black box to reduce insurance costs

Nearly half of young drivers in the South West deem the black box scheme ‘unfair’ according to new research* by insurance comparison website, Quote Goat.

The research, which surveyed 1,000 young drivers in the UK aged 17-24 on their perception of car insurance, found that 43% of young drivers in the South West are unhappy having to rely on schemes like the black box to reduce insurance costs - particularly as many come with restrictions such as driving curfews.

However, when questioned on other cost-saving methods such as their use of Dashcams, respondents in the South West admitted to not installing an insurer-approved Dashcam in their vehicle, despite 46% advising they are aware that this could in fact lower their insurance premium.

Other key take outs of the research include:

▪ Over a third of young drivers throughout the UK pay up to £1,000 per annum for their insurance, with a quarter paying up to £2,000. Just 8% of respondents pay maximum of £2,000 - £4,000.

▪ Car ownership is lower among young drivers in Bristol, with just 57% of respondents advising that they own their own vehicle compared to75% in Wales and 76% in London.

▪ When questioned on the recent MP debate as to whether insurance should be applied to the driver or the vehicle, young drivers posed a near even split - with 58% believing it should still be applied to the driver, and the remaining 42% supporting a change in law through insuring individual vehicles.

On discussing the results, Founder and Managing Director of Quote Goat, Michael Foote, said: “Car insurance has become increasingly expensive for young drivers in recent years, with many having to rely on schemes like black box to lower their annual premiums.

“Despite a massive 77% of all participants utilising the scheme, not even a third of young drivers felt it to be fair or beneficial – implying the majority have compromised with the schemes restrictions to receive a more affordable insurance cost. At Quote Goat, we work hard to deliver extremely competitive quotes for young drivers, ensuring they understand all fundamentals that come into play with insurance costs, from pass plus schemes to choosing vehicles with less modifications.”

This research comes following reports that insurance premiums are set to rocket in 2018, where experts predict young drivers will be hit the hardest.

Chris Stone, 21, agrees with Quote Goat’s findings, also deeming it unfair that Young Drivers have to rely on schemes like Black Box in order to reduce annual insurance premiums.

Chris first started his driving lessons in late 2015, and after 5 attempts, passed in January 2018. Although excited to have finally passed his test, Chris was shocked to discover his annual insurance premium as £1,700. Through the Black Box Scheme Chris was able to reduce this fee to £970, but is forced to pay monthly as he was unable to commit to the one-off fee in full.

He confirmed: “I finally past my driving test in January 2018, following four failed attempts. Like all young drivers, I was extremely excited to have passed, but felt quickly disgruntled when I learnt the cost of my insurance. I live in a countryside location, where my car is always parked on a private drive, however the annual premium was still quoted at a painful £1,700. The only way I was able to reduce this fee was by using the Black Box scheme, enabling me to save £730, with an annual premium of £970.”

“I’m in no way surprised to hear that over half of young drivers feel it’s unfair that we have to rely on the Black Box scheme to make insurance more affordable. If it didn’t reduce my costs by such a staggering amount, I would have not have signed up to it, as conditions such as the time of day or night I am allowed to drive are extremely restrictive.”

Launched in 2009, Quote Goat is quickly becoming one of the UK’s leading insurance comparison sites, offering instant quotes on vehicle, household and business insurance.

Visit the Quote Goat website here.

*The Quote Goat Young Drivers research was carried out via the Google Surveys platform.


Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Cotswold Life visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Cotswold Life staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Cotswold Life account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

More from Cotswold Life

Fri, 12:03

The Cotswolds are abundant with picture perfect locations ideal for a ramble. Gather loved ones, wrap up warm and blow away the cobwebs with one of these winter walks in the region

Read more
Fri, 11:53

Helping clients through divorce, separation and disputes over children, we talk to 8 divorce lawyers in the Cotswolds

Read more
Fri, 11:52

We’ve some extraordinary, and inspiring, women in business in the Cotswolds. We talk to 7 female trailblazers in local industry who offer the business advice they’ve lived by

Read more
Wed, 16:26

Swan Lake. We know the music, we know the iconic imagery of the beautiful ballerina dressed as a swan, but I’m guessing that without reading the libretto in the program, most people don’t know the story. Which is why the audience relies on the dancers to tell us.

Read more
Wed, 11:00

Tom and Louise are being joined by other new academic appointments that have been made as part of the RAU’s £2.5 million initiative to help meet the future needs of the land management and agri-food sectors

Read more
Wed, 10:46

“To win this prestigious award is a real compliment to the wider team in Renishaw’s manufacturing services operation, particularly when we consider the achievements of the other excellent shortlisted companies.”

Read more
Tue, 17:16

Stepping up to receive the world’s first MBA Leading Business degrees at the ceremony were Sarah Bryars, Chief Executive of Target; Luke Freeman, Joint Chief Executive of MF Freeman; and Linsey Temple, Chief Executive of Gloucestershire Engineering Training

Read more
Tue, 17:04

“I am thrilled to see InfoSec People win this fantastic award which is a testament to the brilliant team we have built in the past few years.”

Read more
Tue, 16:36

After a stress-free shopping experience browsing designer brands this Christmas? Look no further than the luxury offerings of Mailbox in Birmingham

Read more
Tue, 10:24

This year sees the 40th anniversary of the publication of Raymond Briggs’ original picture book The Snowman. With three performances of the animated film – with live orchestra – coming to Gloucester Cathedral next month, we thought we’d catch up with Rachel Whibley, managing director of Carrot Productions (and occasional snowman), to find out more...

Read more
Mon, 14:10

It’s the season of terrible puns, magic lamps, and generous genies: Aladdin, the all-new panto at the Everyman, has been written by none other than legendary Blue Peter presenter Peter Duncan, and stars everyone’s favourite clown, Tweedy. The Barnard family from Nailsworth - mum, dad, Harriet (12) and Lewis (6) - made a Wishee (Washee) for tickets; grabbed their car (Window Twan) keys; and dashed off to see A Ladd In Cheltenham

Read more
Mon, 13:45

Crispy, frosty days and perhaps even a dusting of snow, winter is a magical time in the Cotswolds. If you’re thinking of tying the knot during this beautiful season in the region, here are six winter wedding ideas to help you start planning your special day

Read more

Christmas in the Wilson household is a heartwarming, traditional family affair

Read more
Mon, 13:15

Tracy Spiers takes an impressive, if hypothetical, budget on a shopping spree in Cheltenham’s independent stores

Read more

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Topics of Interest

Food and Drink Directory A+ Education

Subscribe or buy a mag today

subscription ad

Local Business Directory

Property Search